In a Lonely Place
|In a Lonely Place|
|Directed by||Nicholas Ray|
|Produced by||Robert Lord|
|Based on||In a Lonely Place|
by Dorothy B. Hughes
|Music by||George Antheil|
|Edited by||Viola Lawrence|
|Color process||Black and white|
|Distributed by||Columbia Pictures|
|Box office||$1.4 million|
In a Lonely Place is a 1950 American film noir directed by Nicholas Ray and starring Humphrey Bogart and Gloria Grahame, produced for Bogart's Santana Productions. The script was written by Andrew P. Solt from Edmund H. North's adaptation of Dorothy B. Hughes' 1947 novel of the same name.
Bogart stars as Dixon (Dix) Steele, a troubled, and violence-prone, screenwriter suspected of murder. Grahame co-stars as Laurel Gray, a lonely, foolish neighbor who falls under his spell. Beyond its surface plot of confused identity and tormented love, the story is a mordant comment on Hollywood mores and the pitfalls of celebrity and near-celebrity, similar to two other American films released that same year, Billy Wilder's Sunset Boulevard and Joseph L. Mankiewicz's All About Eve.
Although lesser-known than his other work, Bogart's performance is considered by many critics to be among his finest and the film's reputation has grown over time, along with Ray's. It is now considered as one of the best film noirs of all time, as evidenced by its inclusion on the Time "All-Time 100 Movies" list as well as Slant Magazine's "100 Essential Films" and is ranked number one on "The 100 Best Film Noirs of All Time". The BBC ranked it number 89 in their list of the 100 greatest American films of all time. In 2007, In a Lonely Place was selected for preservation in the United States National Film Registry by the Library of Congress as being "culturally, historically, or aesthetically significant."
Dixon "Dix" Steele is a down-on-his-luck Hollywood screenwriter who has not had a successful movie since before World War II. While driving to meet his agent, Mel Lippman, Steele's explosive temper is revealed when, at a stoplight, he engages with another motorist in a confrontation that almost becomes violent. Meeting with Lippman at a nightclub, Steele is cajoled into adapting a book for a movie. The hat-check girl, Mildred Atkinson, is engrossed in reading the copy meant for Steele; since she only has a few pages left to go, she asks to be allowed to finish it. Steele claims to be too tired to read the novel, so he asks Mildred to go home with him to explain the plot. As they enter the courtyard of his apartment, they pass a new tenant, Laurel Gray. Mildred describes the story, confirming what Steele had suspected—the book is no good. Rather than drive her home as promised, he gives her cab fare instead.
The next morning, Steele is awakened by a police detective named Brub Nicolai, who served under Steele during the war. Nicolai takes him downtown to be questioned by his superior, who reveals that Mildred was murdered, and Steele is a suspect. Nicolai also brings Gray in for questioning. When he gets home, Steele checks up on Gray. He finds she is an aspiring actress with only a few low-budget films to her credit. They begin to fall in love and, with Gray assisting him, Steele enthusiastically goes back to work, much to Lippman's delight.
At a dinner with Nicolai and his wife, Steele has them re-enact the murder; his odd behavior leads Nicolai's wife Sylvia to doubt Steele's innocence. Lochner sows seeds of doubt in Gray's mind, pointing out Steele's long record of violent behavior. At a nightclub, Steele spots Ted Barton, another detective, arrive with a female companion and grows irritated, believing that Barton is tailing him. Later, at Steele's apartment, Gray's masseuse Martha warns her about Steele's checkered romantic past, and Gray grows irritated, kicking her out of the apartment. At a beach party with the Nicolais, Sylvia inadvertently reveals Gray's secret meeting with Lochner, causing Steele to become furious as he storms away from the beach. Steele leaves the beach with Gray and drives erratically until they sideswipe another car. Nobody is hurt, but when the other driver accosts him, Steele beats him unconscious and is about to strike him with a large rock when Gray stops him.
Steele goes to the police station and attempts to clear his name, meeting Atkinson's boyfriend Harry Kesler, who works at a bank. Steele remarks to Nicolai that Kesler is a better suspect. At the Nicolai residence, Gray asks Sylvia about the night where they were made to re-enact the murder, revealing Steele's roadside assault. Eventually, Gray's doubts about Steele's innocence result in her being unable to sleep without taking pills. When he asks her to marry him, she accepts, but only because she is too scared of what he might do if she refused. Lippman comes over to celebrate while Steele is away, only to find out that Gray does not want to go through with the marriage and is making plans to escape to New York. At a dinner to celebrate the engagement, Frances Randolph, an actress whom Steele previously dated, joins and reveals that Steele's script has been leaked by Lippman. Steele then takes a call meant for Gray at the table, discovering it is Martha and slugging Lippman when he tries to intervene.
Back at the apartment, Steele flies into a rage. After briefly calming down, Steele answers the phone, learning of Gray's flight cancellation. He again becomes violent, almost strangling her before he regains control of himself. The phone rings again. Nicolai reveals that Kesler confessed and attempted suicide. It is too late, however, to salvage Steele and Gray's relationship.
- Humphrey Bogart as Dixon Steele
- Gloria Grahame as Laurel Gray
- Frank Lovejoy as Det. Sgt. Brub Nicolai
- Carl Benton Reid as Captain Lochner
- Art Smith as Mel Lippman
- Martha Stewart as Mildred Atkinson
- Jeff Donnell as Sylvia Nicolai
- Robert Warwick as Charlie Waterman
- Morris Ankrum as Lloyd Barnes
- William Ching as Ted Barton
- Steven Geray as Paul, Headwaiter
- Hadda Brooks as Singer
When Edmund H. North adapted the story, he stuck close to the original source and John Derek was considered for the role of Steele because in the novel the character was much younger. North's treatment was not used. Andrew Solt developed the screenplay with regular input from producer Robert Lord and director Nicholas Ray, and the end result is far different from the source novel. Solt claimed that Bogart loved the script so much that he wanted to make it without revisions – Solt maintains that the final cut is very close to his script – but further research shows that Ray made regular rewrites, some added on the day of shooting. In fact, only four pages of the 140-page script had no revisions. The film was produced by Bogart's Santana Productions company, whose first film was Knock on Any Door (1949), which was directed by Ray and starred Bogart and Derek in the leading roles.
Louise Brooks wrote in her essay "Humphrey and Bogey" that she felt it was the role of Dixon Steele in this movie that came closest to the real Bogart she knew. "Before inertia set in, he played one fascinatingly complex character, craftily directed by Nicholas Ray, in a film whose title perfectly defined Humphrey's own isolation among people. In a Lonely Place gave him a role that he could play with complexity because the character's pride in his art, his selfishness, his drunkenness, his lack of energy stabbed with lightning strokes of violence, were shared equally by the real Bogart." Apparently, on one voyage in their yacht Santana, Bogart showed an inexplicable burst of rage that frightened his wife Lauren Bacall.
The original ending had Steele strangling Gray to death in the heat of their argument. Sgt. Nicolai comes to tell Steele that he has been cleared of Mildred's murder but arrests him for killing Gray. Steele tells Brub that he is finally finished with his screenplay; the final shot was to be of a page in the typewriter which has the significant lines Steele said to Gray in the car (which he admitted to not knowing where to put) "I was born when she kissed me, I died when she left me, I lived a few weeks while she loved me". This scene was filmed halfway through the shooting schedule, but Ray hated the ending he had helped write. Ray later said,
"I just couldn't believe the ending that Bundy (screenwriter Andrew Solt) and I had written. I shot it because it was my obligation to do it. Then I kicked everybody off stage except Bogart, Art Smith and Gloria. And we improvised the ending as it is now. In the original ending we had ribbons so it was all tied up into a very neat package, with Lovejoy coming in and arresting him as he was writing the last lines, having killed Gloria. Huh! And I thought, shit, I can't do it, I just can't do it! Romances don't have to end that way. Marriages don't have to end that way, they don't have to end in violence. Let the audience make up its own mind what's going to happen to Bogie when he goes outside the apartment."
Bacall and Ginger Rogers were considered for the role of Laurel Gray. Bacall was a natural choice given her off-screen marriage to Bogart and their box-office appeal, but Warner Bros. refused to loan her out, a move often thought to be in reaction to Bogart having set up his own independent production company, the type of which Warner Bros. were afraid would jeopardize the future of the major studios. Rogers was the producers' first choice but Ray believed that his wife Gloria Grahame was right for the part. Even though their marriage was troubled, he insisted that she be cast. Her performance today is unanimously considered to be among her finest.
Grahame and Ray's marriage was starting to come apart during filming. Grahame was forced to sign a contract stipulating that "my husband [Ray] shall be entitled to direct, control, advise, instruct and even command my actions during the hours from 9 AM to 6 PM, every day except Sunday ... I acknowledge that in every conceivable situation his will and judgment shall be considered superior to mine and shall prevail." Grahame was also forbidden to "nag, cajole, tease or in any other feminine fashion seek to distract or influence him." The two did separate during filming. Afraid that one of them would be replaced, Ray took to sleeping in a dressing room, lying and saying that he needed to work on the script. Grahame played along with the charade and nobody knew that they had separated. Though there was a brief reconciliation, the couple divorced in 1952.
At the time of its original release, the reviews were generally positive (in particular many critics praised Bogart and Grahame's performances), but many questioned the marketability given the bleak ending. The staff at Variety magazine in May 1950 gave the film a good review and wrote, "In In a Lonely Place Humphrey Bogart has a sympathetic role though cast as one always ready to mix it with his dukes. He favors the underdog; in one instance he virtually has a veteran, brandy-soaking character actor (out of work) on his very limited payroll ... Director Nicholas Ray maintains nice suspense. Bogart is excellent. Gloria Grahame, as his romance, also rates kudos".
Bosley Crowther lauded the film, especially Bogart's performance and the screenplay, writing, "Everybody should be happy this morning. Humphrey Bogart is in top form in his latest independently made production, In a Lonely Place, and the picture itself is a superior cut of Lippmanodrama. Playing a violent, quick-tempered Hollywood movie writer suspected of murder, Mr. Bogart looms large on the screen of the Paramount Theatre and he moves flawlessly through a script which is almost as flinty as the actor himself. Andrew Solt, who fashioned the screenplay from a story by Dorothy B. Hughes and an adaptation by Edmund H. North, has had the good sense to resolve the story logically. Thus Dixon Steele remains as much of an enigma, an explosive, contradictory force at loose ends when the film ends as when it starts."
Not unlike Ray's debut They Live by Night (1948), it was advertised as a straight thriller although the film does not fit easily into one genre, as the marketing shows. Ray's films had a brief revival in the 1970s and Bogart's anti-hero stance gained a following in the 1960s, and the French Cahiers du cinéma critics during the 1950s praised Ray's unique film making. Time magazine, which gave the film a negative review upon its initial release, called it one of the 100 best films of all time in their 2005 list.
Critic Ed Gonzalez wrote in 2001, "Not unlike Albert Camus' The Stranger, Nicholas Ray's remarkable In a Lonely Place represents the purest of existentialist primers ... Gray and Dixon may love each other but it's evident that they're both entirely too victimized by their own selves to sustain this kind of happiness. In the end, their love resembles a rehearsal for the next and hopefully less complicated romance. This is the existential endgame of one of Ray's smartest and most devastating masterpieces."
Curtis Hanson is featured on the retrospective documentary of the DVD release showing his admiration for the film, notably Ray's direction, the dark depiction of Hollywood and Bogart's performance. This was one of the films which he showed to actors Russell Crowe and Guy Pearce in preparation for filming L.A. Confidential. He said, "I wanted them to see the reality of that period and to see that emotion. This movie, and I'm not saying it's the greatest movie ever made, but it represents many things that I think are worth aspiring to, such as having character and emotion be the driving force, rather than the plot. ... When I first saw In a Lonely Place as a teenager, it frightened me and yet attracted me with an almost hypnotic power. Later, I came to understand why. Occasionally, very rarely, a movie feels so heartfelt, so emotional, so revealing that it seems as though both the actor and the director are standing naked before the audience. When that kind of marriage happens between actor and director, it's breathtaking."
The review aggregator Rotten Tomatoes reported that 98% of critics gave the film positive reviews, with an average rating of 8.71/10, based on 47 reviews. The website's critics consensus reads: "Led by extraordinary performances from Humphrey Bogart and Gloria Grahame, In a Lonely Place is a gripping noir of uncommon depth and maturity."
In popular culture
The 1986 song "In a Lonely Place" by the Smithereens, from the album Especially For You, was inspired by the film. Its chorus, "I was born the day I met you, lived a while when you loved me, died a little when we broke apart," is taken directly from the movie's dialogue.
Comparisons to novel
In a Lonely Place was based on the 1947 novel of the same name by Dorothy B. Hughes. Some controversy exists between admirers of the film and admirers of the novel (who view the film as a watered down adaptation), as Edmund H. North's script takes some elements of the novel but is ultimately a different story. Hughes was not bothered by the changes made by North and praised Grahame's performance as Gray.
The strongest difference between the two works lies in the protagonist; the film's Dixon Steele is a screenwriter with an unconventional life and a decent person with fatally poor impulse control, prone to wild overreaction when enraged. The novel's Steele is a limited third-person view from Steele's perspective, reminiscent of the first-person in noir, à la The Killer Inside Me. Steele is a charlatan who pretends to be a novelist while sponging money from his overbearing uncle. When this well dries up, he murders a wealthy young man and assumes his identity, in a manner similar to Patricia Highsmith's Tom Ripley. (Hughes' character pre-dates Ripley and may have influenced him.) The film follows the question of whether Steele finally went too far in his anger and committed the murder to a tragic end: even though he is proved innocent, his rage at the cloud of suspicion has driven the woman he loves away for good. No question of Steele's innocence exists in the novel, which follows the investigation of a murder Steele plainly committed and his interference in the investigation for his own ends.
Curtis Hanson, in the DVD featurette 'In A Lonely Place Revisited', further analyses the parallels and differences between the novel and the film. He notes that there is a parallel in the film between Steele's adaptation of a novel for film and the adaptation of In a Lonely Place for film. He also notes that a difference between Steele in the film and Steele in the novel is their respective treatment of women. In the novel Steele pursues women and the first chapter details his pursuit of a woman. In the film, Steele is pursued by women.
Hughes' novel was out of print for decades, until re-released by The Feminist Press at CUNY in 2003, which edition was still in print in 2010. Penguin Books published a paperback edition in the UK in 2010 as part of their Modern Classics imprint, and the Library of America included it in the first volume of their "Women Crime Writers" collection. Second-hand copies are readily available.
- "Top Grosses of 1950". Variety. January 3, 1951. p. 58.
- "The 100 Best Film Noirs of All Time". Paste. August 9, 2015. Retrieved August 9, 2015.
- In a Lonely Place at the American Film Institute Catalog.
- Smith, Imogen Sara. "In a Lonely Place: An Epitaph for Love". The Criterion Collection.
- Telotte, J. P. (1989). Voices in the Dark: The Narrative Patterns of Film Noir. Uni. of Illinois Press. pp. 189–195. ISBN 0-252-01570-3.
- In a Lonely Place on Time's "All-Time 100 List"
- "Slant Magazine's 100 Essential Films List". 2007. Archived from the original on 2008-02-14.
- Staff. "The 100 Best Film Noirs of All Time". Retrieved 2020-06-24.
- "The 100 greatest American films". BBC. Archived from the original on December 27, 2020.
- "Complete National Film Registry Listing | Film Registry | National Film Preservation Board | Programs at the Library of Congress | Library of Congress". Library of Congress, Washington, D.C. 20540 USA. Retrieved 2020-11-16.
- "Librarian of Congress Announces National Film Registry Selections for 2007". Library of Congress, Washington, D.C. 20540 USA. Retrieved 2020-11-16.
- Brooks, Louise. Sight and Sound, Winter 1966/67, Volume 36 Number 1, "Humphrey and Bogey." Last accessed: January 20, 2008.
- Eisenschitz, Bernard. "Nicholas Ray: An American Journey" (Great Britain: Faber and Faber Limited, 1993) page 144.
- Lentz, Robert J. (2011). Gloria Grahame, Bad Girl of Film Noir: The Complete Career. Mcfarland. ISBN 978-0-786-43483-1.
- "Gloria Grahame". Glamour Girls of the Silver Screen. Retrieved 2020-05-04. Based on several sources including Curcio, Vincent (1989). Suicide Blonde: The Life of Gloria Grahame (1st ed.). William Morrow. ISBN 0-688-06718-2.
- "In a Lonely Place". Variety. May 17, 1950. Retrieved 2020-05-04.
- Crowther, Bosley (May 18, 1950). "The Screen: Three Films Make Their Bows; Humphrey Bogart Movie, 'In a Lonely Place,' at Paramount --Import at Trans-Lux 'Annie Get Your Gun,' Starring Betty Hutton, Is Presented at Loew's State Theatre". The New York Times.
- Sarris, 1998. p.119
- Gonzalez, Ed (2001). "In a Lonely Place". Slant Magazine. Archived from the original on 2008-02-11.
- Lyman, Rick (December 15, 2000). "A Dark Lesson In Trust". The New York Times.
- Ebert, Roger (August 13, 2009). "In a Lonely Place (1950)".
- In a Lonely Place at Rotten Tomatoes. Last accessed: July 6, 2016.
- "The P.I. Record Collection". The Thrilling Detective. Retrieved 2020-05-14.
|Wikiquote has quotations related to: In a Lonely Place|
|Wikimedia Commons has media related to In a Lonely Place.|
- In a Lonely Place at the American Film Institute Catalog
- In a Lonely Place at IMDb
- In a Lonely Place at AllMovie
- In a Lonely Place at the TCM Movie Database
- In a Lonely Place at Rotten Tomatoes
- In a Lonely Place DVD restoration review at Bright Lights Film Journal
- In a Lonely Place article at Senses of Cinema by Serena Bramble
- In a Lonely Place: An Epitaph for Love an essay by Imogen Sara Smith at the Criterion Collection
- In a Lonely Place essay by Daniel Eagan in America's Film Legacy: The Authoritative Guide to the Landmark Movies in the National Film Registry, A&C Black, 2010 ISBN 0826429777, pages 435-436